Lawyer says no proof; accusers produce no evidence at appeal hearing
By Jeremy Reynalds
Senior Correspondent for ASSIST News Service
ISTANBUL (ANS) -- Accusers who say an Algerian Christian insulted Islam provided no evidence to a judge hearing the Christian's appeal of his original sentence.
According to a story by Open Doors News, Karim Siaghi, a Christian convert, was sentenced in May 2011 to five years in prison and fined 200,000 Algerian Dinars, or about U.S. $2,500, even though prosecutors had brought no evidence or witnesses before the court.
More than a year later, in mid-November, Siaghi's appeal hearing was held in the coastal city of Oran, in the northwest of Algeria. It was the first time he had faced his accuser in court.
Open Doors News said authorities arrested Siaghi in April 2011 after he allegedly gave a CD about Christianity to a Muslim. Siaghi had gone to a phone store to buy airtime minutes for his cell phone, and the clerk there initiated a conversation about religion.
Unhappy with Siaghi's non-Muslim answers, the clerk tried to force him to worship the Prophet and to recite the Muslim shahada, "There is no God but Allah and Muhammad is his Prophet."
When Siaghi refused and said he was a Christian, Open Doors News said the clerk filed a complaint that the convert had belittled the Prophet. Lacking additional witnesses, charges were brought against him.
Open Doors News said the clerk had allegedly seen Siaghi give a CD to someone, but never appeared in court to testify about that. Siaghi's lawyer said there was no evidence of the charges.
Local Algerians as well as international observers were dismayed when the judge handed down the sentence. The prosecutor had reportedly sought a two-year sentence and a fine of 50,000 Algerian dinars, or about U.S. $690.
Open Doors News said experts on Algeria's treatment of Christians say that Algerian courts customarily have preferred to delay deciding in favor of Christians, so as not to aggravate local Muslim feelings. They say judges also have been slow to pronounce final verdicts in order to keep from provoking international criticism over religious freedom.
According to online news source Liberation Algerie, the judge demanded the November hearing to complete any information missing from the case, and to allow the court to confirm whether the accusations deserved the sentence.
Open Doors News said Siaghi "categorically denied, once more, having pronounced the least insult against the Prophet," according to Liberation Algerie. Siaghi was accompanied by his wife and young daughter.
The judge has not yet set a date for the next court hearing, when a ruling is expected to be issued. Protesters who gathered in front of the Criminal Court of Oran on the day of the hearing, however, expressed concern that Siaghi may face another drawn-out legal ordeal, according to Algerian daily L'Expression.
Open Doors News reported that Mustapha Krim, president of the Protestant Church of Algeria, said he hopes during Siaghi's next hearing to mobilize Algerians in protest.
"We are planning on mobilizing the maximum amount of people, Christian or not, to protest the arbitrary character of Law 06-03 of 2006, which in effect allows a person who does not share the values of 'certain Islamists' to be condemned based on word of mouth," Krim said.
Law 06-03 outlaws proselytism of Muslims, as well as the distribution, production and storing of material used for the purpose. It is often quoted in court cases against Christians. The law also prohibits churches from operating without registration.
In 2010, Open Doors News reported, four Christian leaders in Tizi Ouzou were sentenced to several months in jail for worshiping without a permit, but the jail time was suspended.
In 2008 a Christian leader in Tiaret, Rachid Essaghir, received suspended sentences in two separate cases against him for sharing his faith. Though Christians appeal these verdicts, the outcome is rarely conclusive.
Open Doors News said in recent years many Algerians have converted to Christianity, partly because of Christian TV broadcasting in the country. Backlash is common.
According to Open Doors News, last month a man was beaten into a coma by his cousin for watching Christian TV programs. His name and location have been withheld for his security.
A Protestant church in Ouargla, in southern Algeria, was attacked in February resulting in damage to the exterior of the building.
In October, Open Doros News said, four people threatened to burn down the church building.
Open Doors News said in a historic move, the Algerian government in the summer of 2011 officially recognized the Protestant Church of Algeria, authorizing it to act as the council of the country's Protestant churches. The church was established in 1972, though until 2011 only the Catholic Church had government recognition. Despite the recognition of the Protestant Church of Algeria, churches still are required to obtain their own registration.
Algeria was ranked 23rd in the 2012 World Watch List of the 50 countries where it is most difficult to be a Christian. The list cited increasing pressure on Christians, including discrimination by the state and family members.
The World Watch List said Islamist groups are becoming more active in their pursuits to influence government, and are monitoring the activities of Christians.
For more information go to www.opendoorsnews.org